The League

Draft retrospective

Every steal.
Every reach.

Grades use league-scored production above positional replacement, compared with the historical expectation for each exact draft slot.

20252024202320222021

2023 report card

Draft grades

150 of 150 picks produced NFL statistics
#1 · mattmoneymilsA+

Injury Report Squad

Best value
Raheem Mostert Pick 106 · A+
Biggest miss
Dalvin Cook Pick 66 · F
Open full draft →
#2 · WhiteSeanA

GM Bill Belichick

Best value
James Cook Pick 74 · A+
Biggest miss
Jalin Hyatt Pick 147 · C-
Open full draft →
#3 · 2ShaanezA-

chief chungus

Best value
Jalen Hurts Pick 30 · A+
Biggest miss
Kadarius Toney Pick 110 · D
Open full draft →
#4 · tdurkin2B+

Team NITRO

Best value
Dak Prescott Pick 137 · A+
Biggest miss
JuJu Smith-Schuster Pick 117 · D
Open full draft →
#5 · billdabz710B

Terp Town GlobSquad

Best value
CeeDee Lamb Pick 16 · A+
Biggest miss
Dameon Pierce Pick 45 · D
Open full draft →
#6 · jimmydoyleB-

Sparkling Wiggles

Best value
Christian McCaffrey Pick 1 · A+
Biggest miss
Aaron Rodgers Pick 101 · F
Open full draft →
#7 · tjam19C+

SUPER Chargers

Best value
Rachaad White Pick 69 · A+
Biggest miss
Nick Chubb Pick 9 · F
Open full draft →
#8 · BDBOSSC

Best D in the League

Best value
James Conner Pick 78 · A-
Biggest miss
Deshaun Watson Pick 98 · F
Open full draft →
#9 · GoodMojoeC-

The Wieners

Best value
Travis Etienne Pick 28 · A+
Biggest miss
Anthony Richardson Pick 133 · F
Open full draft →
#10 · bdurkindoD

bdurkindo

Best value
Isiah Pacheco Pick 79 · A+
Biggest miss
Daniel Jones Pick 139 · F
Open full draft →

Pick by pick

The draft board

PickPlayerTeamPtsPos rankGradeValue
1
Christian McCaffreyRB · Round 1
Sparkling Wiggles356.801A+144.86
2
Justin JeffersonWR · Round 1
bdurkindo138.2038D-87.55
3
Austin EkelerRB · Round 1
Best D in the League151.5029C--53.44
4
Travis KelceTE · Round 1
Team NITRO172.902B--10.67
5
Ja'Marr ChaseWR · Round 1
Terp Town GlobSquad207.8210C+-25.08
6
Tyreek HillWR · Round 1
Injury Report Squad299.202A+69.80
7
Saquon BarkleyRB · Round 1
GM Bill Belichick180.0016C-27.74
8
Bijan RobinsonRB · Round 1
The Wieners193.7012C+-16.14
9
Nick ChubbRB · Round 1
SUPER Chargers21.1085F-190.84
10
Stefon DiggsWR · Round 1
chief chungus207.1012C+-23.70
11
Derrick HenryRB · Round 2
chief chungus215.368B10.72
12
Davante AdamsWR · Round 2
SUPER Chargers200.8013C+-16.80
13
Cooper KuppWR · Round 2
The Wieners134.9039D-91.00
14
A.J. BrownWR · Round 2
GM Bill Belichick237.205B11.30
15
Josh JacobsRB · Round 2
Injury Report Squad160.6023C-36.04
16
CeeDee LambWR · Round 2
Terp Town GlobSquad305.701A+89.20
17
Patrick MahomesQB · Round 2
Team NITRO346.227C-29.88
18
Tony PollardRB · Round 2
Best D in the League177.5018B--14.64
19
Garrett WilsonWR · Round 2
bdurkindo161.3030C-44.10
20
Amon-Ra St. BrownWR · Round 2
Sparkling Wiggles247.503A-42.90
21
DeVonta SmithWR · Round 3
Sparkling Wiggles187.1018B--13.70
22
Najee HarrisRB · Round 3
bdurkindo158.2026C+-18.84
23
Mark AndrewsTE · Round 3
Best D in the League111.9012C-42.92
24
Tee HigginsWR · Round 3
Team NITRO116.6046D-75.20
25
Rhamondre StevensonRB · Round 3
Terp Town GlobSquad126.7033C-39.44
26
Josh AllenQB · Round 3
Injury Report Squad436.581A+88.84
27
Joe MixonRB · Round 3
GM Bill Belichick216.807A53.16
28
Travis EtienneRB · Round 3
The Wieners242.203A+80.06
29
Jaylen WaddleWR · Round 3
SUPER Chargers162.6029C+-16.56
30
Jalen HurtsQB · Round 3
chief chungus412.222A+71.62
31
Jahmyr GibbsRB · Round 4
chief chungus206.109A-47.46
32
Calvin RidleyWR · Round 4
SUPER Chargers171.3025B--10.70
33
Chris OlaveWR · Round 4
The Wieners174.7020B-4.90
34
Lamar JacksonQB · Round 4
GM Bill Belichick381.224A-44.18
35
DeAndre HopkinsWR · Round 4
Injury Report Squad172.0023B-3.60
36
Deebo SamuelWR · Round 4
Terp Town GlobSquad208.509B+32.80
37
Keenan AllenWR · Round 4
Team NITRO225.868A-50.16
38
DK MetcalfWR · Round 4
Best D in the League190.9014B+15.80
39
Breece HallRB · Round 4
bdurkindo222.506A+68.36
40
Kenneth WalkerRB · Round 4
Sparkling Wiggles175.3020B+21.16
41
George KittleTE · Round 5
Sparkling Wiggles170.704A-37.28
42
Joe BurrowQB · Round 5
bdurkindo182.1624F-154.88
43
Amari CooperWR · Round 5
Best D in the League190.0015B15.30
44
Aaron JonesRB · Round 5
Team NITRO102.3040C--51.84
45
Dameon PierceRB · Round 5
Terp Town GlobSquad76.2050D-78.54
46
D'Andre SwiftRB · Round 5
Injury Report Squad177.8017B+23.06
47
DJ MooreWR · Round 5
GM Bill Belichick230.107A55.50
48
Justin FieldsQB · Round 5
The Wieners256.5618D-79.48
49
Justin HerbertQB · Round 5
SUPER Chargers277.6616C--57.28
50
Terry McLaurinWR · Round 5
chief chungus161.1031B--12.40
51
T.J. HockensonTE · Round 6
chief chungus171.503A-40.88
52
Darren WallerTE · Round 6
SUPER Chargers80.2024C-46.72
53
J.K. DobbinsRB · Round 6
The Wieners10.70104F-133.64
54
Alexander MattisonRB · Round 6
GM Bill Belichick113.8036C-30.54
55
Evan EngramTE · Round 6
Injury Report Squad153.406B+25.18
56
Miles SandersRB · Round 6
Terp Town GlobSquad72.3054C--72.04
57
Drake LondonWR · Round 6
Team NITRO133.7840C-28.50
58
Tyler LockettWR · Round 6
Best D in the League146.8034B--13.80
59
Cam AkersRB · Round 6
bdurkindo41.2063F-98.94
60
Mike EvansWR · Round 6
Sparkling Wiggles239.304A+78.70
61
Jonathan TaylorRB · Round 7
Sparkling Wiggles119.3035C+-18.94
62
Dallas GoedertTE · Round 7
bdurkindo105.9014B--6.22
63
Mike WilliamsWR · Round 7
Best D in the League40.70108F-109.30
64
Brandon AiyukWR · Round 7
Team NITRO207.7011A57.70
65
Alvin KamaraRB · Round 7
Terp Town GlobSquad195.5011A66.46
66
Dalvin CookRB · Round 7
Injury Report Squad32.7072F-96.14
67
Christian WatsonWR · Round 7
GM Bill Belichick87.3061C--62.50
68
Kyle PittsTE · Round 7
The Wieners107.1013B-0.72
69
Rachaad WhiteRB · Round 7
SUPER Chargers223.605A+94.56
70
Chris GodwinWR · Round 7
chief chungus159.2033B9.20
71
Javonte WilliamsRB · Round 8
chief chungus138.7031B8.26
72
George PickensWR · Round 8
SUPER Chargers174.0021B+22.60
73
Christian KirkWR · Round 8
The Wieners121.7643C-28.04
74
James CookRB · Round 8
GM Bill Belichick202.0010A+73.68
75
Zay FlowersWR · Round 8
Injury Report Squad167.9027B+27.90
76
Brandin CooksWR · Round 8
Terp Town GlobSquad132.0041B--7.30
77
David MontgomeryRB · Round 8
Team NITRO188.2014A68.36
78
James ConnerRB · Round 8
Best D in the League159.6024A-39.76
79
Isiah PachecoRB · Round 8
bdurkindo191.9013A+72.06
80
Jerry JeudyWR · Round 8
Sparkling Wiggles98.4054C-42.40
81
New York JetsDEF · Round 9
Sparkling Wiggles421.0010B+21.30
82
San Francisco 49ersDEF · Round 9
bdurkindo425.005B+26.00
83
Jahan DotsonWR · Round 9
Best D in the League97.6055C-41.70
84
Philadelphia EaglesDEF · Round 9
Team NITRO399.0019B-0.90
85
Trevor LawrenceQB · Round 9
Terp Town GlobSquad291.3415B--10.30
86
Michael PittmanWR · Round 9
Injury Report Squad189.8016A50.90
87
David NjokuTE · Round 9
GM Bill Belichick160.705A+72.98
88
Marquise BrownWR · Round 9
The Wieners109.2051C+-20.70
89
Gabe DavisWR · Round 9
SUPER Chargers138.9037B10.60
90
Diontae JohnsonWR · Round 9
chief chungus109.3050C+-19.00
91
Dallas CowboysDEF · Round 10
chief chungus418.0012B+30.00
92
Zach CharbonnetRB · Round 10
SUPER Chargers82.6047C+-24.74
93
AJ DillonRB · Round 10
The Wieners106.6039B0.00
94
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR · Round 10
GM Bill Belichick115.4047B--12.00
95
Khalil HerbertRB · Round 10
Injury Report Squad97.4041B--6.64
96
Pat FreiermuthTE · Round 10
Terp Town GlobSquad57.7030C+-27.68
97
Antonio GibsonRB · Round 10
Team NITRO97.3042B--9.30
98
Deshaun WatsonQB · Round 10
Best D in the League101.8035F-181.94
99
Elijah MitchellRB · Round 10
bdurkindo30.8073D-73.24
100
Ezekiel ElliottRB · Round 10
Sparkling Wiggles137.4032B+33.36
101
Aaron RodgersQB · Round 11
Sparkling Wiggles0.0071F-286.44
102
Jordan AddisonWR · Round 11
bdurkindo172.6022A-45.90
103
Courtland SuttonWR · Round 11
Best D in the League160.0032B+32.44
104
Michael ThomasWR · Round 11
Team NITRO70.3079C--56.40
105
Brian RobinsonRB · Round 11
Terp Town GlobSquad169.1021A63.36
106
Raheem MostertRB · Round 11
Injury Report Squad252.202A+146.46
107
Baltimore RavensDEF · Round 11
GM Bill Belichick453.001A68.30
108
Rashaad PennyRB · Round 11
The Wieners2.70118F-103.04
109
Buffalo BillsDEF · Round 11
SUPER Chargers435.003A-48.90
110
Kadarius ToneyWR · Round 11
chief chungus38.50111D-88.20
111
Adam ThielenWR · Round 12
chief chungus175.3019A-48.60
112
Treylon BurksWR · Round 12
SUPER Chargers31.90117F-97.90
113
Quentin JohnstonWR · Round 12
The Wieners71.7076C--57.00
114
Odell BeckhamWR · Round 12
GM Bill Belichick90.0059C-38.70
115
New England PatriotsDEF · Round 12
Injury Report Squad395.0022B5.50
116
Samaje PerineRB · Round 12
Terp Town GlobSquad90.8044B--14.64
117
JuJu Smith-SchusterWR · Round 12
Team NITRO46.5097D-80.20
118
Rashod BatemanWR · Round 12
Best D in the League60.5084C--61.80
119
Skyy MooreWR · Round 12
bdurkindo43.20104D-86.60
120
Jamaal WilliamsRB · Round 12
Sparkling Wiggles39.9064C--66.32
121
Elijah MooreWR · Round 13
Sparkling Wiggles102.6052C+-23.80
122
Jaylen WarrenRB · Round 13
bdurkindo159.4025A53.96
123
Jerick McKinnonRB · Round 13
Best D in the League73.8652C+-26.38
124
Dalton SchultzTE · Round 13
Team NITRO114.3011A-35.28
125
Allen LazardWR · Round 13
Terp Town GlobSquad48.6095D-72.60
126
Damien HarrisRB · Round 13
Injury Report Squad18.0090D-78.94
127
De'Von AchaneRB · Round 13
GM Bill Belichick164.6022A67.66
128
Dalton KincaidTE · Round 13
The Wieners101.9015B+25.38
129
Tyler HigbeeTE · Round 13
SUPER Chargers85.0021B9.68
130
Tank BigsbyRB · Round 13
chief chungus20.7086D-76.24
131
Cole KmetTE · Round 14
chief chungus138.007A62.68
132
Tua TagovailoaQB · Round 14
SUPER Chargers322.7410A50.70
133
Anthony RichardsonQB · Round 14
The Wieners77.6839F-194.36
134
Greg DulcichTE · Round 14
GM Bill Belichick4.0094C--64.42
135
Dawson KnoxTE · Round 14
Injury Report Squad34.4048C-38.42
136
Rashee RiceWR · Round 14
Terp Town GlobSquad172.0024A54.10
137
Dak PrescottQB · Round 14
Team NITRO387.683A+108.74
138
Kenneth GainwellRB · Round 14
Best D in the League74.1851C+-23.56
139
Daniel JonesQB · Round 14
bdurkindo63.9643F-216.18
140
Jameson WilliamsWR · Round 14
Sparkling Wiggles67.3081C--50.20
141
Kirk CousinsQB · Round 15
Sparkling Wiggles187.7422D-92.00
142
Deuce VaughnRB · Round 15
bdurkindo11.50101D-86.24
143
New Orleans SaintsDEF · Round 15
Best D in the League388.0026B10.60
144
Pittsburgh SteelersDEF · Round 15
Team NITRO423.007A-45.40
145
Miami DolphinsDEF · Round 15
Terp Town GlobSquad412.0014B+34.85
146
Jared GoffQB · Round 15
Injury Report Squad334.308A55.36
147
Jalin HyattWR · Round 15
GM Bill Belichick46.8096C--70.65
148
Seattle SeahawksDEF · Round 15
The Wieners422.508A-45.40
149
Deon JacksonRB · Round 15
SUPER Chargers1.50129F-94.99
150
Darnell MooneyWR · Round 15
chief chungus63.4082C--55.80

With hindsight

How it should have gone

1Christian McCaffreyRB · originally 1356.80
2CeeDee LambWR · originally 16305.70
3Tyreek HillWR · originally 6299.20
4Josh AllenQB · originally 26436.58
5Raheem MostertRB · originally 106252.20
6Travis EtienneRB · originally 28242.20
7Kyren WilliamsRB · undrafted238.00
8Jalen HurtsQB · originally 30412.22
9Amon-Ra St. BrownWR · originally 20247.50
10Rachaad WhiteRB · originally 69223.60
11Breece HallRB · originally 39222.50
12Mike EvansWR · originally 60239.30
13Joe MixonRB · originally 27216.80
14A.J. BrownWR · originally 14237.20
15Derrick HenryRB · originally 11215.36
16Puka NacuaWR · undrafted232.90
17DJ MooreWR · originally 47230.10
18Sam LaPortaTE · undrafted184.90
19Jahmyr GibbsRB · originally 31206.10
20Dak PrescottQB · originally 137387.68