The League

Draft retrospective

Every steal.
Every reach.

Grades use league-scored production above positional replacement, compared with the historical expectation for each exact draft slot.

20252024202320222021

2025 report card

Draft grades

147 of 150 picks produced NFL statistics
#1 · bdurkindoA+

Jetardinals

Best value
Christian McCaffrey Pick 15 · A+
Biggest miss
Joe Burrow Pick 35 · F
Open full draft →
#2 · GoodMojoeA

Not last place.

Best value
Jaxon Smith-Njigba Pick 36 · A+
Biggest miss
Kaleb Johnson Pick 85 · F
Open full draft →
#3 · WhiteSeanA-

Stiff-Armed and Dangerous

Best value
James Cook Pick 33 · A+
Biggest miss
James Conner Pick 48 · F
Open full draft →
#4 · tdurkin2B+

Team NITRO

Best value
Travis Etienne Pick 71 · A+
Biggest miss
Tyreek Hill Pick 30 · F
Open full draft →
#5 · BDBOSSB

IttyBittyGriddyCommittee

Best value
Jonathan Taylor Pick 18 · A+
Biggest miss
Braelon Allen Pick 103 · D
Open full draft →
#6 · Heckster23B-

Failures

Best value
Jaylen Warren Pick 92 · A+
Biggest miss
Jayden Daniels Pick 32 · F
Open full draft →
#7 · jimmydoyleC+

Sparkling Wiggles

Best value
Bijan Robinson Pick 2 · A+
Biggest miss
Joe Mixon Pick 102 · F
Open full draft →
#8 · mattmoneymilsC

Injury Report Squad

Best value
Javonte Williams Pick 101 · A+
Biggest miss
Lamar Jackson Pick 21 · F
Open full draft →
#9 · tjam19C-

SUPER Chargers

Best value
De'Von Achane Pick 14 · A+
Biggest miss
Kyler Murray Pick 107 · F
Open full draft →
#10 · billdabz710D

Terp Town GlobSquad

Best value
Chris Olave Pick 84 · A+
Biggest miss
Brandon Aiyuk Pick 124 · F
Open full draft →

Pick by pick

The draft board

PickPlayerTeamPtsPos rankGradeValue
1
Ja'Marr ChaseWR · Round 1
Injury Report Squad231.505B15.30
2
Bijan RobinsonRB · Round 1
Sparkling Wiggles324.503A+129.65
3
Justin JeffersonWR · Round 1
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee145.1029D-64.10
4
Saquon BarkleyRB · Round 1
Terp Town GlobSquad213.8013B18.95
5
Jahmyr GibbsRB · Round 1
Not last place.308.604A+106.60
6
CeeDee LambWR · Round 1
Jetardinals162.5018C--50.20
7
Malik NabersWR · Round 1
SUPER Chargers48.1098F-163.90
8
Derrick HenryRB · Round 1
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous258.407A58.50
9
Ashton JeantyRB · Round 1
Failures205.7015B-3.70
10
Amon-Ra St. BrownWR · Round 1
Team NITRO245.103B+31.00
11
Josh JacobsRB · Round 2
Team NITRO218.1012B23.40
12
Nico CollinsWR · Round 2
Failures190.708C+-10.20
13
Puka NacuaWR · Round 2
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous289.501A80.30
14
De'Von AchaneRB · Round 2
SUPER Chargers288.305A+93.30
15
Christian McCaffreyRB · Round 2
Jetardinals354.901A+168.20
16
Brian ThomasWR · Round 2
Not last place.108.4044D-91.40
17
Drake LondonWR · Round 2
Terp Town GlobSquad152.1024C-45.86
18
Jonathan TaylorRB · Round 2
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee333.402A+151.20
19
Josh AllenQB · Round 2
Sparkling Wiggles420.621B+29.64
20
Bucky IrvingRB · Round 2
Injury Report Squad113.2037C--60.50
21
Lamar JacksonQB · Round 3
Injury Report Squad232.4421F-153.94
22
Brock BowersTE · Round 3
Sparkling Wiggles144.208C-28.30
23
Chase BrownRB · Round 3
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee229.1010A63.00
24
Omarion HamptonRB · Round 3
Terp Town GlobSquad118.7033C-42.20
25
A.J. BrownWR · Round 3
Not last place.181.3010B-10.90
26
Trey McBrideTE · Round 3
Jetardinals242.901A+82.10
27
Kyren WilliamsRB · Round 3
SUPER Chargers235.708A82.00
28
Ladd McConkeyWR · Round 3
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous147.9025C+-18.50
29
Tee HigginsWR · Round 3
Failures166.4015B-3.94
30
Tyreek HillWR · Round 3
Team NITRO43.00107F-119.46
31
Jalen HurtsQB · Round 4
Team NITRO353.068C+-12.12
32
Jayden DanielsQB · Round 4
Failures132.2834F-235.30
33
James CookRB · Round 4
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous281.206A+132.50
34
George KittleTE · Round 4
SUPER Chargers127.6011C+-22.50
35
Joe BurrowQB · Round 4
Jetardinals145.3232F-215.86
36
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR · Round 4
Not last place.287.002A+128.00
37
Terry McLaurinWR · Round 4
Terp Town GlobSquad87.5057D-71.50
38
Marvin HarrisonWR · Round 4
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee107.3045C--51.10
39
Mike EvansWR · Round 4
Sparkling Wiggles65.4076F-93.00
40
Breece HallRB · Round 4
Injury Report Squad191.6617A-47.46
41
TreVeyon HendersonRB · Round 5
Injury Report Squad171.4020B+26.70
42
DK MetcalfWR · Round 5
Sparkling Wiggles157.7022B--1.20
43
Alvin KamaraRB · Round 5
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee84.2046C--59.60
44
Chuba HubbardRB · Round 5
Terp Town GlobSquad107.7041C-36.50
45
Patrick MahomesQB · Round 5
Not last place.337.1811C+-24.10
46
Kenneth WalkerRB · Round 5
Jetardinals160.1023B15.30
47
Courtland SuttonWR · Round 5
SUPER Chargers181.709B+23.80
48
James ConnerRB · Round 5
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous28.3077F-115.40
49
Garrett WilsonWR · Round 5
Failures80.5061D-76.30
50
Isiah PachecoRB · Round 5
Team NITRO77.8051D-64.80
51
Sam LaPortaTE · Round 6
Team NITRO86.9024C--60.40
52
David MontgomeryRB · Round 6
Failures149.9226B-11.72
53
Jameson WilliamsWR · Round 6
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous177.0011B+28.40
54
RJ HarveyRB · Round 6
SUPER Chargers179.3019A-44.90
55
Davante AdamsWR · Round 6
Jetardinals192.907A-39.20
56
Tony PollardRB · Round 6
Not last place.160.3022B+25.90
57
Xavier WorthyWR · Round 6
Terp Town GlobSquad88.9056C--56.68
58
DJ MooreWR · Round 6
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee145.5828B-1.68
59
Aaron JonesRB · Round 6
Sparkling Wiggles103.7043C-26.50
60
George PickensWR · Round 6
Injury Report Squad240.004A+96.10
61
Calvin RidleyWR · Round 7
Injury Report Squad38.80113F-103.70
62
Zay FlowersWR · Round 7
Sparkling Wiggles172.5012B+34.90
63
Tetairoa McMillanWR · Round 7
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee167.9014B+34.60
64
Rashee RiceWR · Round 7
Terp Town GlobSquad121.6041C+-11.70
65
D'Andre SwiftRB · Round 7
Not last place.206.3014A+87.20
66
Brian RobinsonRB · Round 7
Jetardinals57.6060C--61.30
67
DeVonta SmithWR · Round 7
SUPER Chargers156.6023B23.50
68
Jerry JeudyWR · Round 7
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous92.5052C-40.80
69
Tyrone TracyRB · Round 7
Failures118.9032B--0.20
70
Deebo SamuelWR · Round 7
Team NITRO147.1026B13.80
71
Travis EtienneRB · Round 8
Team NITRO230.609A+110.10
72
T.J. HockensonTE · Round 8
Failures87.3023C-38.60
73
Baker MayfieldQB · Round 8
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous311.7012C+-23.68
74
Travis HunterWR · Round 8
SUPER Chargers48.8096D-83.78
75
Jaylen WaddleWR · Round 8
Jetardinals161.1220A-37.82
76
Travis KelceTE · Round 8
Not last place.152.504A-38.70
77
Mark AndrewsTE · Round 8
Terp Town GlobSquad103.6016C+-11.70
78
Ricky PearsallWR · Round 8
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee70.6072C--53.50
79
Quinshon JudkinsRB · Round 8
Sparkling Wiggles156.8024A-46.90
80
Evan EngramTE · Round 8
Injury Report Squad71.8031C-43.50
81
Emeka EgbukaWR · Round 9
Injury Report Squad162.9017A-39.60
82
Jordan AddisonWR · Round 9
Sparkling Wiggles112.8043B--9.80
83
Matthew GoldenWR · Round 9
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee54.2090D-68.40
84
Chris OlaveWR · Round 9
Terp Town GlobSquad219.006A+95.50
85
Kaleb JohnsonRB · Round 9
Not last place.7.30103F-102.00
86
Rome OdunzeWR · Round 9
Jetardinals124.1040B-1.90
87
Jakobi MeyersWR · Round 9
SUPER Chargers131.4036B18.20
88
Khalil ShakirWR · Round 9
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous130.4037B17.20
89
Stefon DiggsWR · Round 9
Failures162.0019A50.40
90
Cam SkatteboRB · Round 9
Team NITRO115.7035B18.30
91
Chris GodwinWR · Round 10
Team NITRO65.2078C-46.40
92
Jaylen WarrenRB · Round 10
Failures183.7018A+86.30
93
Jacory Croskey-MerrittRB · Round 10
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous131.9029A-35.24
94
Jordan MasonRB · Round 10
SUPER Chargers110.5039B14.00
95
Zach CharbonnetRB · Round 10
Jetardinals154.2025A60.10
96
David NjokuTE · Round 10
Not last place.69.8032C-32.26
97
Jauan JenningsWR · Round 10
Terp Town GlobSquad140.3031B+29.44
98
Tyler WarrenTE · Round 10
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee144.407A47.60
99
Cooper KuppWR · Round 10
Sparkling Wiggles89.9053C+-18.40
100
Austin EkelerRB · Round 10
Injury Report Squad10.6095D-83.50
101
Javonte WilliamsRB · Round 11
Injury Report Squad225.3011A+131.20
102
Joe MixonRB · Round 11
Sparkling Wiggles0.00—F-95.80
103
Braelon AllenRB · Round 11
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee14.3093D-82.36
104
Brock PurdyQB · Round 11
Terp Town GlobSquad220.2023D-92.08
105
Keon ColemanWR · Round 11
Not last place.75.5064C-34.50
106
Bo NixQB · Round 11
Jetardinals353.307A-41.02
107
Kyler MurrayQB · Round 11
SUPER Chargers92.7838F-217.80
108
Tucker KraftTE · Round 11
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous101.2018B-0.00
109
J.K. DobbinsRB · Round 11
Failures110.4040B14.90
110
Philadelphia EaglesDEF · Round 11
Team NITRO439.002A74.60
111
Colston LovelandTE · Round 12
Team NITRO116.0014B14.80
112
Rashid ShaheedWR · Round 12
Failures125.4039B12.30
113
Nick ChubbRB · Round 12
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous81.8049C+-16.00
114
Josh DownsWR · Round 12
SUPER Chargers99.8048C+-12.20
115
Jake FergusonTE · Round 12
Jetardinals145.106A-40.80
116
Justin HerbertQB · Round 12
Not last place.346.8810B+34.90
117
Jayden HigginsWR · Round 12
Terp Town GlobSquad99.7049C+-10.30
118
Keenan AllenWR · Round 12
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee133.1034B+27.50
119
Jayden ReedWR · Round 12
Sparkling Wiggles39.00112D-74.10
120
Ollie GordonRB · Round 12
Injury Report Squad49.0064C-47.28
121
Denver BroncosDEF · Round 13
Injury Report Squad410.509A-46.40
122
Najee HarrisRB · Round 13
Sparkling Wiggles10.1097D-85.40
123
Dak PrescottQB · Round 13
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee379.084A72.30
124
Brandon AiyukWR · Round 13
Terp Town GlobSquad0.00—F-104.50
125
Tank BigsbyRB · Round 13
Not last place.35.2069C--55.10
126
Pittsburgh SteelersDEF · Round 13
Jetardinals434.003A78.40
127
Trey BensonRB · Round 13
SUPER Chargers30.9071C--56.10
128
Darnell MooneyWR · Round 13
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous60.8081C-41.20
129
Minnesota VikingsDEF · Round 13
Failures413.008A57.80
130
Rhamondre StevensonRB · Round 13
Team NITRO128.5031A-41.50
131
Jared GoffQB · Round 14
Team NITRO353.826A50.74
132
Michael PittmanWR · Round 14
Failures160.3021A66.40
133
Amari CooperWR · Round 14
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous0.00—F-93.90
134
Houston TexansDEF · Round 14
SUPER Chargers416.006A67.70
135
Rachaad WhiteRB · Round 14
Jetardinals117.9034B+33.80
136
Cedric TillmanWR · Round 14
Not last place.46.7099C--54.50
137
Jaydon BlueRB · Round 14
Terp Town GlobSquad6.50106D-80.10
138
Jordan LoveQB · Round 14
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee282.1414C+-22.14
139
Dalton KincaidTE · Round 14
Sparkling Wiggles99.3020B-6.10
140
Isaac TeSlaaWR · Round 14
Injury Report Squad65.6075C-35.20
141
Kyle WilliamsWR · Round 15
Injury Report Squad43.70102C--57.90
142
Baltimore RavensDEF · Round 15
Sparkling Wiggles392.5014A-36.10
143
San Francisco 49ersDEF · Round 15
IttyBittyGriddyCommittee346.0029B--9.40
144
Green Bay PackersDEF · Round 15
Terp Town GlobSquad359.5027B-3.90
145
Tampa Bay BuccaneersDEF · Round 15
Not last place.388.0017B+32.85
146
Tyler AllgeierRB · Round 15
Jetardinals113.6036B+27.00
147
Dylan SampsonRB · Round 15
SUPER Chargers65.7056C+-20.85
148
Washington CommandersDEF · Round 15
Stiff-Armed and Dangerous376.5021B21.40
149
C.J. StroudQB · Round 15
Failures233.2820D-69.75
150
Christian KirkWR · Round 15
Team NITRO43.70103C--58.80

With hindsight

How it should have gone

1Christian McCaffreyRB · originally 15354.90
2Jonathan TaylorRB · originally 18333.40
3Bijan RobinsonRB · originally 2324.50
4Jahmyr GibbsRB · originally 5308.60
5De'Von AchaneRB · originally 14288.30
6James CookRB · originally 33281.20
7Puka NacuaWR · originally 13289.50
8Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR · originally 36287.00
9Derrick HenryRB · originally 8258.40
10Trey McBrideTE · originally 26242.90
11Kyren WilliamsRB · originally 27235.70
12Amon-Ra St. BrownWR · originally 10245.10
13Travis EtienneRB · originally 71230.60
14Chase BrownRB · originally 23229.10
15George PickensWR · originally 60240.00
16Javonte WilliamsRB · originally 101225.30
17Josh JacobsRB · originally 11218.10
18Ja'Marr ChaseWR · originally 1231.50
19Saquon BarkleyRB · originally 4213.80
20D'Andre SwiftRB · originally 65206.30